News Release
For Immediate Release: 11.17.26
Contact: Peyton Drew, media@firstliberty.org
Direct: 972-941-4453
U.S. Supreme Court Urged to Clarify Federal Law’s Protection of Religious Land Use
Federal law provides clear protections for how faith-based organizations can use their property to support their mission.
Washington, DC—Attorneys from First Liberty Institute, Quinn Emanuel, Dinsmore & Shohl LLP, and Breidenstein Legal Services, LLC representing the Missionaries of St. John the Baptist filed their merits brief with the Supreme Court of the United States urging the Justices to vacate a decision by the Kentucky Supreme Court denying the group’s right to build a modest shrine for quiet prayer and reflection on their own property. Oral argument is set for January 20, 2027.
You can read the brief here.
“Stopping a religious group from building a modest place for prayer and reflection on its own property is outrageous,” said Kelly Shackelford, President, CEO, and Chief Counsel at First Liberty. “Federal law provides clear protections for how faith-based organizations can use their property to support their mission. This is a hugely important case for religious freedom.”
John Bash, partner and co-chair of Quinn Emanuel’s national appellate practice, said, “Congress acted to protect religious organizations from unlawful burdens within local zoning laws and the protests of neighbors. We are grateful for the opportunity to present this important case before the Supreme Court.”
In March 2021, Missionaries of St. John the Baptist applied for a conditional use permit and variance to construct a small, modest grotto behind its building in honor of the Virgin Mary’s apparition in Lourdes, France to Saint Bernadette. In Catholicism, a grotto is a sacred, cave-like shrine, often artificial, and built to honor the Virgin Mary or saints. It serves as a quiet space for prayer, reflection, and devotion, symbolizing divine refuge and miracles. These structures can be found in churches, gardens, or even as roadside shrines, creating a focal point for faith and spiritual solace. The church building has resided on the current property for nearly 100 years and predates the adoption of the City of Park Hills’ zoning ordinance in 1974. The Park Hills Board of Adjustment approved St. John’s permit in April 2021 for the construction of the grotto.
Two neighbors adjacent to the property objected and appealed the Board’s decision to Kentucky state court. The trial court rejected the neighbors’ objections, but the Kentucky Court of Appeals reversed on appeal, holding that a ban of the grotto did not violate RLUIPA. The Kentucky Supreme Court affirmed that holding in December 2025.
The case allows the Supreme Court to clarify the proper standards under the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (“RLUIPA”), which prohibits unlawful burdens on religious land use.
In the merits brief, attorneys state, “Congress enacted RLUIPA because existing zoning and landmarking regimes were suppressing religious exercise, and the statute puts local governments to a demanding burden before they may prevent landowners from using their property for religious activities. In response to these unlawful burdens, Congress codified a basic principle: except when the implementation of a land use regulation satisfies strict scrutiny, the choice of where the exercise of religion can take place should be left to persons with rights of access to and use of real property—not to zoning codes and landmarking laws promulgated by governments.”
###
About First Liberty Institute
First Liberty Institute is a non-profit public interest law firm and the largest legal organization in the nation dedicated exclusively to defending religious freedom for all Americans.
To arrange an interview, contact John Manning at media@firstliberty.org.