News

The Fight for Pro-Life Free Speech: Overturning Hill v. Colorado

Share:
November 20, 2026
Pro-Life | First Liberty Insider

by Roger Byron, Senior Counsel • 3 minutes

The right to free speech means that the government can’t squash or silence messages it doesn’t like. Neither can it punish the people who voice those messages. Preventing that kind of government action is why the Founders adopted the First Amendment.

The real First Amendment.

As the late U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia pointed out, however, there is “an entirely separate, abridged edition of the First Amendment” at work in some of the Supreme Court’s jurisprudence. This abridged First Amendment says you get all the free speech protections of the First Amendment – unless. It says the First Amendment fully applies to you – unless.

And that ‘unless’ is the undoing of free speech.

For many years now, the Court has relegated to second-class status the speech rights of those who advocate a pro-life position on the issue of abortion. This practice of jettisoning legal rules and doctrines to safeguard abortion has been so prevalent, Justice Scalia gave it a name:  the “ad hoc nullification machine.”

The poster child for the machine’s distortion of basic free speech doctrine is Hill v. Colorado, which the Court handed down in 2000.

The issue in Hill was a Colorado law that makes it a crime for anyone within 100 feet of the door of an abortion center to get within eight feet of another person to hand her a pamphlet or say anything that could be construed as “education” or “counseling.” You can’t get close enough to hand her a brochure that tells how she could get help. Or to offer her more information about the irreversible, life altering procedure she is considering. Or to tell her about abortion alternatives, if she’d like to hear them.

The only escape is to somehow get the woman’s permission before getting close enough to talk to her (i.e., within eight feet) while on a noisy street or sidewalk. That’s like saying you can use sign language but you have to put your hands behind your back.

The law is absurd and contravenes basic free speech law. It never would have survived if it hindered climate change advocates or a labor union demonstration outside a manufacturing plant.  In Hill, however, the Court activated the ad hoc nullification machine and upheld the law as perfectly fine under the First Amendment.

Since then, Hill has been roundly criticized as bad law. Its reasoning was, and is, incompatible with the (real) First Amendment.  Supreme Court decisions since Hill have made it even clearer that it is irreconcilable with free speech.  It is so bad that in the landmark decision Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which struck down Roe v. Wade, the Court formally recognized that its abortion jurisprudence had “distorted” the First Amendment and used Hill as its example.

First Liberty Institute filed a federal lawsuit to overturn Hill and have this Colorado law and a similar Denver ordinance struck down as unconstitutional.  The case currently is on appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

We represent Wendy Faustin, a mother of eight and now a grandmother, who firmly believes that abortion is a terrible moral wrong. She has spent many years of her life compassionately and lovingly trying to persuade women to choose an alternative to abortion.

She does this with gentle, one-on-one conversations as a sidewalk counselor, at the only place and time she realistically can: outside abortion centers as women enter them to consider or obtain an abortion.

The First Amendment says she has every right to do so. These state and local laws, however, empowered by the Supreme Court’s abridged First Amendment, have made it nearly impossible for her.

That is anathema to our Constitution.

If the First Amendment rights of Mrs. Faustin and others with a pro-life viewpoint can be set aside at the whim of those in power, no one’s speech rights are safe.

No one’s.

If the right to free speech is to endure, Hill must be overturned and the ad hoc nullification machine demolished. We intend to do just that.

Social Facebook Social Instagram Twitter X Icon | First Liberty Institute Social Youtube Social Linkedin

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • State Disclosures • Sitemap • © 2026 Liberty Institute® is a trademark of First Liberty Institute